Michigan Medical Malpractice: How to Prove Negligence
Meet The Lee Steinberg Law Firm
Not every bad medical outcome is malpractice. Medicine involves risk, and even careful providers cannot guarantee a perfect result. A Michigan medical malpractice claim requires proof that a healthcare provider failed to meet the applicable standard of care and that this failure caused harm.
That sounds simple. In practice, medical malpractice cases are among Michigan's most technical injury claims. They require thorough medical record reviews, expert support, strict pre-suit notice, and careful timing.
The Lee Steinberg Law Firm helps patients and families determine whether a medical injury may result from medical negligence. Call **1-800-LEE-FREE** for a free case evaluation.
Medical malpractice can also arise after another injury. A patient injured in a Michigan car accident claim, Michigan motorcycle accident claim, or Michigan bicycle accident claim may later need a separate review if negligent treatment worsens the injury.
What Counts as Medical Malpractice?
Medical malpractice occurs when a healthcare professional or facility acts, or fails to act, below the accepted standard of care and causes injury. The standard of care is what a reasonable healthcare provider in the same specialty would do under the same or similar circumstances. Not all medical mistakes are medical malpractice. A breach of the standard of care occurs only when a mistake is made that a reasonable healthcare provider would not have made. Examples may include:
- Failure to diagnose
- Delayed diagnosis
- Surgical error
- Medication error
- Birth injury
- Anesthesia error
- Failure to monitor
- Hospital-acquired injury
- Failure to order appropriate testing
- Discharging a patient too soon
In many ways, medical malpractice cases resemble other personal injury cases. For example, a car crash is based upon the violation of Michigan traffic laws. A Michigan slip-and-fall premises liability case focuses on dangerous property conditions, notice, and whether the property owner used reasonable care. Medical malpractice also focuses on whether a doctor, nurse, or other medical professional violated safety rules while providing medical treatment. However, medical malpractice cases require experienced Michigan medical malpractice lawyers with the resources and expertise to litigate successfully
The key issue is not just whether the provider made a mistake. The question is whether the provider breached the professional standard of care under the circumstances.
The Four Core Elements
Most malpractice cases turn on four elements: duty, breach, causation, and damages. This is found in MCL 600.2912a.
- **Duty** means a doctor-patient relationship existed, or the provider otherwise owed a legal duty.
- **Breach** means the doctor failed to provide the patient with the recognized standard of acceptable professional practice or care in the community in which the defendant practices or in a similar community, and that as a proximate result of the defendant failing to provide that standard, the plaintiff suffered an injury.
- **Causation** means the breach caused the injury. This is often the hardest part. A patient may have been seriously ill already, so the attorney must show how the negligence changed the outcome and caused serious injuries that would not have otherwise resulted.
- **Damages** means the patient suffered measurable harm, such as additional treatment, pain and suffering, lost wages, loss of earning capacity, disability, loss of function, or death.
Why Expert Review Matters
Medical malpractice claims always require medical expert analysis. This is different compared to other personal injury cases, such as a car accident. A qualified expert in the same speciality and subspecialty as the negligent doctor must explain what the doctor should have done, how the care fell short, and how that failure caused the injury.
For example, in a delayed cancer diagnosis case, the expert may need to answer:
- What tests should have been ordered given the patient's blood work or symptoms that raised concern?
- Were the results of the tests properly read and analyzed?
- What diagnoses should have been made and when?
- Did the delay in making the diagnosis change the outcome and health of the patient?
Without expert support, it is impossible to prove that the outcome resulted from negligence rather than the underlying condition. In fact, under Michigan law, expert options are required before a lawsuit can even get filed.
Besides being required by law, many medical malpractice cases turn into a “battle of the experts.” That is why it is so important to hire a Michigan medical malpractice lawyer who has access to the best experts across the country. A good expert can make or break your case.
Michigan Notice of Intent Requirement
Michigan medical malpractice claims generally require a Notice of Intent (NOI) before filing a lawsuit. MCL 600.2912b. The notice goes to the healthcare professional or facility informing them the plaintiff intends to file a lawsuit. The NOI must contact certain information, including (1) the factual basis of the claim, (2) the applicable standard of care, (3) the manner in which it is claimed the standard of care was breached, (4) the actions that should been taken to achieve compliance with the standard of care, and (5) the manner in which the breach caused the injury.
Within 154 days of receiving the Notice of Intent, the healthcare provider of the facility must respond to the NOI. The patient then must wait 182 days after providing the NOI before filing a lawsuit. This waiting period is meant to give the parties a chance to settle. During this time, our medical malpractice lawyers will discuss the claim with the lawyers for the doctors or facilities. If settlement is not possible, we then file a medical malpractice lawsuit.
This pre-suit requirement makes timing especially important. Waiting too long can create statute-of-limitations problems.
Affidavit of Merit
Michigan malpractice cases also require an affidavit of merit. This is a sworn statement from a qualified health professional supporting the medical malpractice claim. The expert witness signing the Affidavit of Merit must meet specific requirements. MCL 600.2169.
- Practice in the same speciality as the defendant, if the defendant is a specialist. If the defendant is a specialist and is board certified in that speciality, your expert must match both of those criteria. For example, if the negligent physician is a board-certified cardiologist, your expert must also be a board-certified cardiologist.
- In addition, the board certified expert must devote a majority of their professional time to the active clinical practice (or teaching) of the speciality.
The Affidavit of Merit must set forth (1) the applicable standard of care, (2) how the standard of was breached, (3) the actions that should have been taken (or omitted) to follow the standard of care, and (4) the manner in which the breach of the standard of care was the proximate cause of the injury. The Affidavit of Merit is filed with the lawsuit or Complaint.
Michigan Medical Malpractice Deadlines
Michigan medical malpractice claims generally have a two-year limitations period from the act or omission that forms the basis of the claim. Michigan law also recognizes certain discovery and repose rules, but these rules are technical and fact-specific.
The safest approach is to speak with a Michigan medical malpractice lawyer as soon as you suspect malpractice. We will then obtain, review, and evaluate medical records to determine if a medical malpractice case is possible. We will then prepare proper notice.
Evidence Used to Prove Negligence
The strongest malpractice cases are built from detailed evidence, including:
- The deposition testimony of the defendant doctor
- The deposition testimony of other medical personnel
- Complete medical records
- Lab results and imaging
- Medication administration records
- Nursing notes
- Operative reports
- Discharge instructions
- Prior medical history
- Expert opinions
- Timeline of symptoms and treatment
- Witness accounts from family members or caregivers
Patients and families should write down what happened while memories are fresh. Dates, names, symptoms, calls, and instructions can matter.
Common Defenses in Medical Malpractice Cases
Healthcare providers and insurers may argue:
- The doctor or healthcare professional met the standard of care
- The injury was a known complication
- The patient had a poor prognosis regardless of treatment
- The patient did not follow instructions
- Another provider caused the harm
- The claim was filed too late
These defenses are why early investigation matters. A strong case must connect the medical facts to the legal elements.
What Compensation May Be Available?
A malpractice claim may seek compensation for medical expenses, future care, lost income, loss of earning capacity, pain and suffering, disability, and loss of enjoyment of life. These are called economic damages.
However, a medical malpractice victim and their family is also entitled to receive “non-economic” damages. These damages include pain and suffering, mental anguish, loss of social pleasures and disfigurement. These harms and losses cannot be found in medical bills or lost wages. Instead, a great Michigan medical malpractice lawyer will explain to the judge, jury and insurance company the lasting harm the malpractice has caused. This can range from the affect on the plaintiff’s day-to-day life, the emotional trauma, and most importantly the physical pain and suffering the victim must suffer through every single day.
Unfortunately, in Michigan there are caps to the amount of non-economic damages a malpractice victim may collect from the insurance carrier of the healthcare provider or hospital. There are actually two caps. The first cap is currently $596,400 and the high cap is currently $1,065,000. The higher cap is if a person suffered paralysis, permanent damage, or loff the ability to have children.
In fatal cases, the claim will be for wrongful death damages. Oddly, death cases are subject to the lower medical malpractice cap!
How Our Michigan Medical Malpractice Attorneys Can Help
Our attorneys can review the timeline, request medical records, consult qualified experts, evaluate deadlines, and explain whether the facts may support a malpractice claim. Medical malpractice cases differ from ordinary injury claims, but we may still handle the fee structure on a contingency basis. You can learn more in Free Consultation and No Win, No Fee: How Our Fees Work.
Free Consultation
If you believe a medical provider's mistake caused serious harm, a free consultation can help determine whether we should review the facts for malpractice. Bring medical records, discharge papers, medication lists, appointment summaries, and a written timeline if you have them.
Call Lee Steinberg Law Firm at **1-800-LEE-FREE** to discuss your options.
FAQ - Frequently Asked Questions
Is a bad result enough to prove malpractice?
No. You must show the provider breached the standard of care and that the breach caused injury.
Do I need a medical expert?
Yes. Expert support is central to proving the standard of care, breach, and causation. Without expert opinions backing up your medical malpractice claim, there is no case.
What is a Notice of Intent?
It is a pre-suit notice generally required before filing a Michigan medical malpractice lawsuit. It is meant to help facilitate settlement between the parties.
How long do I have to file a Michigan malpractice claim?
Many claims involve a two-year limitations period, but exceptions and additional rules may apply. Get legal advice quickly.
