A common question we get at the Lee Steinberg Law Firm is can I sue the other driver after a car accident in Michigan? The answer is much more complex than one would think. First, there can be several different defendants. Second, there are rules about injuries and insurance that must be followed. Also, the type of crash, whether it is a motorcycle accident or bicycle crash is important. That is why it is important to contact a team of great Michigan car accident lawyers to help answer your questions.

Getting into a car accident or truck accident in Michigan is different than in other states. Because Michigan is a no-fault state, some certain rules and requirements exist that do not exist elsewhere. The differences begin right after the crash, from who pays for the medical bills, to who pays to fix your car, to who pays for pain and suffering for injuries.

Because of the no-fault law, figuring out who you can sue after a car accident and for what is not so straightforward. This article sets out to explain Michigan car accident law in more detail and outline the rules.

Can I Sue the Driver in Michigan After An Accident?

Yes. So long as the other driver is at-least 50% at-fault for causing the crash, then the driver is responsible for the injuries he or she causes. Typically, the insurance company for the driver will cover the payment of injuries. However, the injured person must prove the other driver was negligent in causing the injuries.

How Do I Prove Driver Negligence?

The police report can go a long way in proving fault. The report will provide basic information about the drivers and their auto insurance. It will also include a narrative that describes how the police believe the car accident happened. Usually, the police will assign a “hazardous action” to the at-fault driver.

However, the key evidence is the testimony of the people involved in the crash and witnesses to the accident. Police reports are not admissible into evidence. And they are often wrong. But the testimony of the parties and witnesses is admissible and very important. That is why it is important to reach out to Michigan car accident lawyers who will start the investigation immediately. Getting witness statements early can be the difference between winning and losing a case.

Can I Sue the Car Owner?

Yes. Under the Michigan Owners’ Liability statute, MCL 257.401, the owner of a car involved in causing the accident can also be sued so long as the owner gave permission to the negligent driver to operate the vehicle at the time of the crash. The owner is liable even if he or she had nothing to do with the car accident. Under this rule, the owner is liable if the car was operated with his or her express or implied consent or knowledge. This consent is presumed when an immediate family member is driving the vehicle – such as a spouse, father, mother, sibling, or child.

What are the Different Claims after a Car Accident?

In Michigan, there are usually three different claims following a car wreck or big truck accident. The first claim is a Michigan no-fault claim or first-party PIP claim. This claim is against a car insurance company and includes payment of medical expenses, lost wages, out-of-pocket expenses, and other similar benefits stemming from a car accident injury.

The second claim is a pain and suffering claim. This is the lawsuit against the driver and owner of the at-fault vehicle. Under the Michigan No-Fault Law, a person who is at least 50% at-fault for causing the crash can be sued for the injuries they cause. This is the same as in other states. However, in Michigan the person who is injured must have a threshold injury to be eligible to receive compensation for their pain and suffering.

The third claim is the property claim for the vehicle damage. Michigan’s mini-tort law permits the victim of a crash to file a lawsuit against the at-fault driver and receive up to $3,000 for repair costs. If you have collision coverage, then your own auto insurance pays for the vehicle repair or the value of the car if totaled. If you only have PLPD, in almost all situations the most you can recover is the $3,000 mini-tort.

Is there a Minimum Injury Requirement in Michigan to Sue After a Car Accident?

Yes. To obtain compensation against a negligent driver, the injured person must demonstrate a “threshold injury.” There are three types of threshold injuries:

Death
Permanent, serious disfigurement
Serious impairment of body function.

Almost all car accidents in Michigan involve the serious impairment of body function threshold. The definition is laid out under MCL 500.3135(5), but in general the impairment must be significant enough to generally change a person’s ability to lead a normal life. The threshold is not very high. For example, a person with a herniated disc, broken bones, or a torn ligament also always qualifies.

However, even less serious injuries that heal faster can qualify. So long as there is an objective injury, like muscle spasms, that affects a person’s ability to lead their normal life, the threshold is reached.

If I’m In a Car Accident, Who Do I Sue?

This depends on the type of claim we are talking about. If a person makes a PIP no-fault claim against a car insurance company – such as Allstate or State Farm – and that carrier refuses to hold up its end of the bargain in paying the medical bills, lost wages, or other benefits, then you can sue the car insurance company. In other words, in a PIP claim, the defendant is the car insurance company.

In cases for pain and suffering, you can sue the driver who caused the accident. However, the liability must be established. This means the at-fault driver must be at-least 50% at-fault for causing the accident. In many situations, such as a rear-end accident, this is not difficult to prove and the police report will act as a guide in explaining who was at-fault for the crash and why.

What Can I Sue the Negligent Driver?

As explained above, the negligent driver and owner are responsible for paying pain and suffering caused by the crash, so long as the accident victim proves he or she has a “serious impairment of body function.”

However, the Michigan no-fault law changed in 2019. Under the new law, many motorists have limited PIP or medical coverage. This means, the auto insurance carrier only must pay the medical bills up until the coverage limit is exhausted. Some drivers and passengers who are eligible for a pain and suffering case do not even carry PIP coverage.

In these situations, the injured person can place outstanding medical bills and lost wages on the at-fault driver and owner as part of the negligence claim. So now under Michigan law, a person can sue for medical bills, lost wages, and pain and suffering when injured in a car or truck accident when PIP benefits run out.

How Much Can Someone Sue For a Car Accident?

Besides the mini-tort limit of $3,000 for the vehicle damage repair costs, there is no limit to what you can sue the other driver for injuries related to a car accident. However, the reality is that cases of pain and suffering or outstanding medical expenses are limited by the amount of insurance involved.

Under the new car accident law, drivers must now purchase bodily injury insurance with limits of $250,000 per person or $500,000 per occurrence, although the law allows drivers to select a lower bodily injury limit of $50,000 per person or $100,000 per occurrence.

Commercial vehicles typically have much higher insurance limits, with interstate carriers federally mandated to have higher insurance policies.

Given the fact that injury victims can now file a lawsuit for not only pain and suffering, but also all medical expenses that result from a collision in Michigan, it is advisable for all drivers to purchase at least $250,000 in coverage to protect themselves. And if they have assets to protect, such as a house, then a much higher limit should be selected or an umbrella policy purchased to protect against a horrible mistake.

Who pays the Medicals Bills After the Car Accident?

Under the Michigan no-fault law, if a person has PIP coverage as part of their car insurance, the car insurance is responsible for paying the medical expenses up to the PIP coverage limit. There is an order under the law that dictates which auto insurance carrier is responsible for paying this PIP coverage.

First, a driver or passenger always starts with their own car insurance first. For example, if a person is injured in a crash and has GEICO Insurance, then GEICO must pay the medical bills related to the crash.

If the driver or passenger does not have auto insurance, then the auto insurance of a resident relative must pay the claim. Resident relatives include siblings, children, a spouse, or other blood-related family members.

If no car insurance is in the household, a claim must be made with the Michigan Assigned Claims Plan, which is managed by the car insurance industry. An application must be completed and delivered to the MACP, and the Plan will assign a car insurance company to pay the medical bills and other outstanding benefits, up to a $250,000 cap.

However, there is one major caveat. If a car owner’s own uninsured vehicle is involved in the accident, then that owner cannot make for no-fault benefits. This is true even if the other car caused the crash. In fact, the uninsured owner cannot even make a claim for pain and suffering. This is a very harsh rule, and it affects people injured in Michigan car accidents on a daily basis. This is why it is so important to insure your car before driving on a Michigan roadway.

The order for who pays medical expenses is the same for pedestrians, bicyclists and other non-occupants:

(1) Own car insurance,

(2) The auto insurance of a resident relative,

(3) Michigan Assigns Claims Plan.

What Do I Do if the At-Fault Driver is Uninsured?

The reality is that more than 20% of Michigan drivers are uninsured. In many parts of the state, that number is much higher. If an uninsured driver caused the crash, you can sue him but getting compensation from them will be extremely difficult. However, if you have “uninsured motorist” coverage – or UM coverage, you can file a claim against your own auto insurance company for pain and suffering compensation.

In some cases, you can file a UM claim even if you don’t have UM insurance. So long as the vehicle you occupied maintains uninsured motorist insurance, then the occupants of that vehicle who are injured in a crash can make a claim for pain and suffering compensation through the UM policy. The insurance policy itself will describe whether occupants can obtain UM coverage.

What if the At-Fault Driver Doesn’t Have Enough Insurance?

In many situations, the injuries from a car accident are worth more than the insurance the at-fault driver or car owner carries. What can you do in that situation? If this is the case, then you can turn to your own auto insurance carrier by making an “underinsured motorist” claim – or UIM claim. UIM coverage is not mandatory, so it all depends on whether the injured person has the coverage or not.

Again, like an uninsured motorist claim, sometimes the vehicle will have UIM coverage and cover the occupants involved in the crash. The insurance policy controls and contacting an attorney to investigate this is important.

Winning Michigan Car Accident Lawyers

The Lee Steinberg Law Firm has helped Michigan car accident and truck accident injury victims for over 50 years. We have obtained hundreds of millions for our clients, helping victims in Detroit, Saginaw, Grand Rapids, Traverse City, and all points in between.

Call us toll-free at 1-800-LEE-FREE (1-800-533-3733). We are always open and never charge anything until we win your case. We look forward to answering your questions and assisting you.

Michigan Bad Faith Insurance Lawsuits: Essential Information for Policyholders

Drunk Walking Pedestrian Accidents: Who’s Liable in Michigan?